FinMattersYOUR FINANCE MATTERS

First home buyers

Rentvesting vs buying your first home

Buy a home to live in, or rent where you want and buy an investment instead? Answer three questions and see which leaves you ahead. Same starting cash, same yearly spend, so the difference is the strategy, not the budget.

Start from an example:
1

About you

$
Two incomes? Enter the main one here and the second in the workings; it matters for tax.
Is this your first home?
$
2

Buy a home to live in

$
Deposit
3

Or rent, and buy an investment

$
$
Deposit
After

After 10 years, if everything were sold

—

This is an estimate for education, based on your assumptions and today’s rules. It isn’t tax, credit or financial advice: speak to an accountant about the tax side, and to a broker about what you could actually borrow.

Cash needed on day one
Monthly cost, year 1
Worth at year 10, if sold

Want the real numbers?

A FinMatters broker can check your actual borrowing capacity, free

We look at your income, expenses and the lenders that suit you, then talk through this scenario with you. No obligation, no cost: we’re paid by the lender if you proceed.

  • Real borrowing capacity across our lender panel
  • Which schemes and concessions you actually qualify for
  • A copy of this comparison, emailed to you

By sending this you agree to FinMatters contacting you about your request. Privacy policy.

Before you decide

  • Would you actually invest the surplus every month, or would it get spent? Rentvesting only works if the difference is banked.
  • How often might you move for work or family? Leases end, and each move costs money.
  • Could you cope with six months of vacancy, a special levy or a 2% rate rise?
  • Would you sleep better owning where you live, even if the spreadsheet says otherwise?
Show me the workingsAll four strategies, charts, negative gearing, tax, sensitivity and every assumption you can change

Assumptions you can change

Defaults are typical figures as at 18 November 2026. Everything recalculates as you type.

You

Who is buying?
$
Residency
Temporary residents pay surcharge duty and surcharge land tax, and miss the first home buyer schemes.
Sets the 5% Deposit Scheme price cap.
$

Growth, rates and rent

% p.a.
% p.a.
Home growth mode
Investment growth mode
Your assumptions, not forecasts. Past growth does not predict future returns.
% p.a.
% p.a.
% p.a.
% p.a.

Also compare

Loans, costs and comparison rules
%
%
yrs
yrs
% pts
$
$
Lenders mortgage insurance
%
% of rent
$
$
$
$
$
%
$
$
years
$
Where surplus cash goes
Offset: the home buyer’s spare cash saves their loan rate tax-free; the investor’s is worth roughly the after-tax rate because the interest was deductible.
% after tax
% of price
% p.a.
% p.a.
%
$
$
How the comparison stays fair: every strategy starts with the same cash and spends the same total each year; whoever spends less banks the difference. Wealth is compared as if everything were sold at the end of the chosen year.

Full comparison

Negative gearing on the investment property

What the investment actually costs you after rent and tax, and when it stops running at a loss.

Property value

What each property is worth, on your growth assumptions.

What you spend each year

Out-of-pocket housing cost after rent received and tax. The gap between lines is what the cheaper strategy banks.

Loan balance and equity

Solid lines are equity; dashed lines are the loan balance.

After-tax net wealth if sold

Sale proceeds after selling costs, loan payout and any capital gains tax, plus banked cash.

Growth sensitivity

Upfront costs side by side

Year by year

How this calculator works

Method

  • Equal footing. Every strategy starts with the same cash and spends the same total each year; the cheaper one banks the difference.
  • Surplus cash sits in an offset by default: tax-free at the home loan rate for the owner, roughly the after-tax rate for the investor.
  • Loans are amortised month by month (P&I, or interest-only then P&I), with your rate change applied from the year you choose. In the live-then-rent strategy the loan reprices to the investor rate when you move out.
  • Investment tax. Rent after vacancy, less management, letting, holding costs, land tax, interest, depreciation and LMI (over five years). A loss reduces tax at each owner’s marginal rate for 2026-27 including the Medicare levy; principal repayments are never deductible. Established properties bought after 9 May 2017 can’t claim second-hand fittings, and buildings from before 1987 get no capital works allowance.
  • Land tax on the investment is estimated from the land share of the price using the state’s current scale; the home you live in is exempt.
  • Capital gains tax on the investment at sale: proceeds less selling costs and cost base (reduced by capital works claimed), 50% discount after 12 months, at each owner’s marginal rate in the year of sale. The home you live in is exempt; a former home rented out is exempt for up to six years of absence.
  • Not modelled: whether a lender would approve either loan, Family Tax Benefit or Child Care Subsidy income tests (rental losses are added back), Medicare levy surcharge, HELP debts, Help to Buy shared equity, Victoria’s temporary off-the-plan concession.

Rules and figures used (checked 18 November 2026)

    This calculator is general information and an educational model only. It does not consider your objectives, financial situation or needs, is not credit, tax or financial advice, and is not a loan pre-approval or a lender’s credit decision. Growth, rent and interest rate assumptions are yours and are hypothetical, not forecasts; past performance does not indicate future results. Government scheme eligibility depends on your circumstances and the rules at the time, which change: confirm with Revenue NSW, the State Revenue Office Victoria, Housing Australia and the ATO, or talk to us.

    Call 1300 130 341Book a call